|
Latest News:
© Kansas City Star, June 29, 2005
Park Hill officials remove book. Caregiver of third-grader had complained.
"I said, 'Well, I think you've made the right decision'."
Virginia Ground
Ghost Train is pulling out of Graden Elementary School.
Park Hill School District officials decided to remove the book from the school's library after the care-giver for a Graden
third-grader called into question its use of profanity and racial slurs.
"It was maybe not the best thing to have in the media cnter where younger children had access to it," said district spokeswoman
Nicole Kirby.
Parkville resident Virginia Ground, 72, raised concerns after her great-granddaughter checked out the book in May. Ground
detailed 25 phrases she considered objectionable and sent the list to school district officials and the local chapter of the
National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, among others.
The district responded by launching its policy for the re-evaluation of media center materials. It took only one step -- a
June 16 conference call between Ground, Graden Principal LuAnn Halverstadt and Assistant Superintendent Gina Chambers -- to
ease Ground's mind. The five-minute conversation began with a verbal commitment from Halverstadt and Chambers to remove the
book from the Graden media center.
"I said, 'Well, I think you've made the right decision'," Ground said last week.
Ground had questioned whether media center staff had read Ghost Train by Jess Mowry before making it available for
Graden students, who range from kindergarten through fifth grade. District policy dictates that every media center item be
evaluated based on professional reviews and recommendations. It was unknown, however, whether media center professionals had
read Ghost Train.
Ground's letter prompted Halverstadt and Chambers to sit down with the book, which follows Remi, a 13-year-old Haitian boy
who moved with his family to Oakland, Calif. He befriends fellow eighth-grader Niya, the tough-talking girl upstairs whose
life experiences include her father's drug-related death. Sprinkled among accounts of the pair's attempt to solve a murder
mystery is social commentary on race relations and violence in the inner city.
Written confirmation of the agreement arrived in Ground's mail last week. Chambers signed the letter.
Kirby said the book had probably been placed in the Graden library because its reading level, independent of the content,
would be appropriate for advanced fifth-graders.
According to an online database search, Ghost Train appeared in three Park Hill schools: Graden, Congress Middle School
and Park Hill South High School.
Officials have no plans to remove it from the middle school or high school, Kirby said.
That doesn't necessarily please Ground, a former elementary school teacher. But she considers her mission accomplished.
"I just wanted to make sure it was out of the elementary schools," Ground said. "That was my crusade."
Mission indeed accomplished, Ms. Ground! Let's rewrite history and lie to our kids by trying to pretend bad things never happened
-- or happen -- and nobody used racial slurs fifty years ago (or anymore). That should help prepare our kids for their futures
in this big wide, wonderful world! What's next on your crusade list, denying that slavery or the Holocaust ever happened,
or that if they did we shouldn't tell our kids about it?
Jess Mowry
Excerpt:
"Yo! Just 'cause I'm a girl don't mean I can't dig a grave!"
Remi paused to lean on the shovel. He was shirtless, dirt-streaked, and his ebony body dripped sweat. He stood waist-deep
in the ground and looked up at Niya. "If you wish. Though actually we are digging up a grave."
"Whatever. Just get outa there an' let me dig awhile."
Remi climbed from the hole and sat with his legs dangling over the edge. Niya took the shovel and jumped down, then went right
to work. Remi watched with something like admiration. Niya had dressed for the job in faded old Levis cut off at the knees,
and her blue chambray shirt was knotted to bare a chocolate-brown middle that Remi found charmingly padded with puppy-chub.
The shirt was otherwise unbuttoned, and grew damp and loose as she dug. Remi pulled his eyes away and glanced toward the small
basement window. The last light of day was fading beyond.
Almost two hours had passed since they had come down here. Niya had brought a candle, and they had carefully scanned the floor
in this corner, discovering a sinking about the right shape and size for a grave. And yet Remi was doubtful. The whole basement
floor was far from level and had shifted and sunk everywhere. But Niya had been determined to dig up a ghost, and the old
shovel they found in the toolshed had still been in good enough shape to use.
Remi's eyes returned to the girl. The rays from the light in the laundry area hardly reached over here. Niya's candle now
burned in an old forty-ounce bottle beside the mounting pile of freashly dug dirt, its soft golden glow casting flickering
shadows over her face.
"Um, Remi? You figure he's all gone to bones by now? What I sayin' is, I seen a real new body on my way home from school
last year, an' I don't think I'd get freaked by just a old skeleton, but I ain't sure I wanna see nuthin' in between."
Remi smiled. "After all this time I am sure there will be only bone." Then he added, "If anything at all."
"You sayin' even bones might be rotted away by now?"
"That is not what I am saying. The deeper we dig, the more doubts I have."
Niya paused in her digging to lean on the shovel and look up at Remi. She wiped sweat from her forehead with the back of her
hand. Droplets glittered like gold in her hair, and her skin glistened warmly. "So, what is it you sayin"?"
"Well, remeber that the ghost train passed my window at three-thirteen? Even if we allow for the time when I could not seem
to move, that still leaves no more than a half-hour for the murderer to bury the body."
Niya glanced down at her feet. "But you told me the train came back about five o'clock."
"Four fifty-three."
"Okay. So that's over a hour an' a half."
"Yes. But also remember that I saw the blanc come out from behind the house, go onto the tracks, pause a few moments
at the switch, and finally walk up the line toward the shipyard. Then it took me about fifteen minutes to search the backyard
and go onto the tracks, and then it was at least another quarter-hour from the time I returned to my room until the train
came past again, unloaded and backing up."
"Well, that's still a hour, Remi. After all, you told me you didn't look at your clock before you ran downstairs. So you don't
really know how long you was there at the window."
"Mmm. True. And as I said, math has never been one of my favorite subjects."
Niya grinned. "Yeah? So just hope your life never depends on it someday!" She began digging again, leaving Remi to ponder
the problem.
Reviews:
Here is an action-packed plot as two contemporary teens try to solve the mystery of a locomotive that rumbles by on rusty
tracks of a half-century ago. In the predawn hours of 1996, a horrified Remi sees a man shot in wartime oakland near the shipyards.
He confides this ghostly vision to his new friend, Niya. Mowry captures the urban slang and attitude.
Niya snorted."Yo, Remi! Get a clue! I don't know what the laws are like where you come from, but this's America! Cops don't
care about dead black people today! What you figure the gonna do 'bout some poor brutha gettin' ... capped fifty years ago?"
Within the novel the characters discuss racial tensions as fact, the cause of myriad inequalities. There is an authentic sound
to the place, time and the injustice. Remi, newly arrived from Haiti, is troubled by the "uncaring and cold" faces.
Remi had seen many such faces on policemen and soldiers, on shop-keepers, clerks and immigration officials. He had seen
those same faces already on American TV. Not all were white, but all seemed to harbor some secret hate.
What will appeal most to the middle reader is the heroic attempts of two adolescents to solve a murder mystery and their efforts
to stop the ghost train that ruses past remi's window every night.
Joanna H. Kraus
School Library Journal: 12/96
Old-fashioned suspense co-exists with a modern-day setting in this short, easy-to-read, and very successful mystery. On Remi
DuMont's first night in his new home, a train thunders past his window and he watches a murder being committed. Remi, 13,
is a recent immigrant from Haiti to Oakland, CA. He shares his father's interest in Voodun and the supernatural. He
soon realizes that the late-night train is a ghost train and the murder reenacted on it nightly actually happened more than
50 years ago. As the boy and his new friend Niya investigate, they put together the pieces of an unsolved crime and an unexplained
disappearance. Then they step into the past to try to right a long-standing wrong. Niya introduces Remi to the slang and customs
of the "hood" while he shares some of his knowledge of Haitian French and his family history with her. Their conversations
are realistically sprinkled with four-letter-words never used by Joe Hardy or Nancy Drew (in English or French) and show an
innocent and healthy appreciation of one another's sexuality, but also have moments of righteous indignation at the plight
of poor minorities. Social concerns are swept aside as the mystery gains momentum and Remi, Niya, and readers are caught up
in a hair-raising, life-and-death struggle with a muderer and with time itself. The ending is surprising and satisfying, but
has a tinge of sorrow.
Susan L. Rogers
Publishers Weekly: 9/96
The author of the explosive Way Past Cool now takes aim at a younger audience, offering another gritty, keenly perceptive
portrait of inner-city life but framing it as a ghostly tale. Haitian immigrant Remi knows that life will be different in
Oakland, Calif., where refrigerators, hot running water and TV are taken for granted. But when he and his parents move into
an apartment in a ramshackle Victorian house, the last thing the 13-year-old expects is to be haunted by a recurring vision
of murder. Every night, while his mother and father sleep, Remi (who has "always had a certain affinity for the supernatural")
hears a "fantome" train "panting puffs like the breath of some huge jungle beast". From his window, he witnesses the ghosts
of two railroad men, one while and one African-American, acting out a deadly scenario. He and his streetwise neighbor, Niya,
draw together to uncover an injustice half a century old. Containing more substance than most thrillers for this age group,
this horror story is underscored by strong social commentary on poverty, waste and materialism.
Reviewed by Wendy Bishop
"it's a big house," thought Remi, as he tried to get to sleep. His bedroom window was sealed shut by what could have been
a century of paint. He tried to open it, when the house began to shake as the engine came closer. It was too dark to see clearly,
but a fierce heat from a headlamp and the shrieking of steal upon steel made Remi crouch low. Then the train passed from Remi's
sight. "Did you sleep well. my son?" asked his mother. "Yes, except for the train in the night." His parents both shrugged
their shoulders. "We did not hear a train." When Remi finds out he is the only one who can hear the train, he decides to ask
Niya, his neighbor living downstairs, for help. Together they find out the truth behind a murder and a ghostly night train
that threatens them with death.
The strength of the book is in the growing relationship between Niya and Remi. The adventure they both take, into a supernatural
realm, is appealing to both young people and adults. Jess Mowry uses jargon popular with African-American inner-city kids
which makes the story seem authentic. The suspense lasts right up to the last chapter. Definitely a book worth reading.
|